On Nov. 9, the College Football Playoff's management committee voted unanimously to expand the field from 12 teams to 24, starting with the 2027 season. The field will be the four Power 4 champions, the top Group of 6 team and 19 at-large teams, with byes for the top eight and the first two rounds played on campus. The Power 4 conference championship games are reported to go away. ESPN keeps the games in a five-year deal reported at nearly $1.7 billion. CFP executive director Rich Clark said plainly that many fans are not in favor.
College basketball has been through this. The NCAA tournament took 32 teams in 1975 and 48 in 1980, then grew a few spots at a time until it reached 64 in 1985. That last step ended the first-round byes, and from then on every champion had to win six games. The reaction at the time was mixed. Big East commissioner Dave Gavitt, one of the game's most prominent leaders, was against it.
The worry then was the worry now: a bigger field makes the regular season count for less. If 64 teams get in, why does February matter? If 24 get in, why does a November Saturday?
The two are not the same. Basketball added games on top of its season. Football is reported to be giving up something it already had, the Power 4 conference championship games, and asking a sport of 12 regular-season games to carry a bracket the size of a small league.
March never got smaller as the field got bigger. Whether December does is the question football will spend the next year arguing about.
The whole story of how basketball's field grew, and every argument it heard along the way, is in this week's Long View: Basketball Already Had This Argument.
Written by